Yayyy!! We have a winner for the Name that Thing Contest. Sara guessed correctly that the "thing" was a former Dixie cup. It's the kind for kids with animal pictures on them and then he soaked it (apparently) and then ripped it up and "pasted" it to the mirror in his bathroom. I guess he was done with it. So Sara will be receiving a gift/prize of handmade greeting cards.
Stay tuned for the next contest.